Chowder for the Soul.

“Ishmael and Queequeg arrive on Nantucket Island… They make their way to the Try Pots restaurant, where the proprietor’s wife, Mrs. Hussey, seats them at a table…then asks them but a single question: “Clam or Cod?”

Ishmael is perplexed…

Only when Ishmael detects “a warm savory steam from the kitchen,” and only when two bowls are subsequently placed before them, is the mystery resolved. Chowder. Clam chowder. And what a chowder it turns out to be.”

Chowder, Chapter15 of Moby-Dick.

Chowder originated almost 300 years ago as a simple, hearty shipboard stew made by fishermen and sailors from France and England. The word itself can be traced back to the French word, chaudière, which refers to a large cauldron or cooking pot used to make stews.  But looking further back in time, chaudière traces back to the Latin word calderia, meaning a place for warming things or a cooking vessel.  Just throwing a little word history at you there.

But how did chowder make it to North America’s cooking pots and soup bowls? 

While At Sea: Breton and Newfoundland fishermen and sailors combined their daily catch with salt pork, onions, and hardtack (hard ship biscuits) in a shared pot.

North America: Immigrants brought the dish to coastal North America, Nova Scotia, and New England, where it adapted to local ingredients like abundant clams and potatoes.

Early Records: An 18th-century journal by botanist Joseph Banks describes a 1766 Labrador fishery chowder, and the first American fish chowder recipe appeared in a Boston newspaper in 1751.

The two chowders we have mostly heard about, perhaps even eaten, are:

New England Clam Chowder:  Made with chopped clams, diced potatoes, onions, and salt pork or bacon in a thick, creamy milk or cream base.  Potatoes took the place of hardtack biscuits.  Yay!

Manhattan Clam Chowder: A tomato-based version that replaces milk and cream with a clear, tangy red broth and includes vegetables like carrots, celery, and onions, but no potatoes.

There are other types of clam chowders primarily geared towards the east coast states of Florida, Delaware and Rhode Island.  They mainly use clear broth instead of a cream base, and the Florida version makes it “muy caliente” with datil peppers.

So, when did basic chowder begin incorporating a larger variety of ingredients, not just clams?

During the 1700s to 1800s and immigration from Europe to the new land, North America, and the newly created United States.  On the east coast, a variety of seafoods could be fished or captured, and made a very delicious addition to the cooking pots.  As settlers moved inland, chicken replaced seafood, and newly grown crops of corn and bell peppers could be added to the potatoes and onions.  Down in the southern states, a fish boil replaced chowder.  While chowder is served in a bowl, the ingredients swimming in a liquid, a fish boil drains away the cooking water. The solid pieces of fish and potatoes are removed from the pot and served dry on a plate, typically slathered in melted butter.

“Alright, thanks for the history lessons”, you’re muttering to yourselves, but why the title, why is chowder good for the soul?

Chowder is good for the soul because its thick, warm, and creamy texture triggers deep emotional comfort, psychological safety, and happy memories of home.  The sight, taste, and scent of foods trigger the brain, and, hopefully, good feelings and memories accompany the meal.  There is a sense of belonging whether to a family, group of friends, or any type of loving relationship; feeling lonely eases away.

Eating a hot soup makes you slow down; holding the bowl with a dish towel, blowing on a spoonful to relieve the temperature that will make it just right to eat.  Just like Goldilocks and the Three Bears, eat it just right, relieve stress, and get ready for a nice soothing nap.  But you don’t want that soup to get too cool, the heat is what is telling your brain, “You’re safe and being cared for, relax, breathe, enjoy the moment.”

…and for the future, when you need that safe, relaxing meal, here’s my recipe for Seafood Chowder.  I used imitation crab meat which is actually a firm white fish made to look like crab, but if I could get my hands on real lump crab meat…sighs with contentment.

 

By the way, a huge “Thank You!” goes out to Shylowe and Patrick Chadd, of The Over Bite, of Monticello.  I called in a hot-minute bread order of items I believed would go great with the chowder.  Croissant Sourdough Bread Loaf, Sourdough Bread Bowls and Corn Muffins, and they were quickly baked up and perfect accompaniments, as I had so believed.  Then there were the very last-minute sandwiches ordered when I went there; Gooseneck Grinder and Comb Ridge Club…so good!  So, need a special order of breads, muffins, other baked goods, or sandwiches, give The Over Bite a call.

Left to Right: Croissant Sourdough Loaf, Sourdough Bread Bowls, Corn Muffins from The Over Bite, Monticello, UT.

 

 

Seafood Chowder

Ingredients:

1/2 cup butter

1 small onion, diced

½ cup diced red bell peppers

1 Tbsp. garlic, minced

4 cups diced, peeled potatoes  

2 cups whole kernel corn (frozen or canned that has been drained and rinsed)

2 and ½ cups water or seafood stock

1 and ½ lbs. medium sized shrimp, peeled and deveined

1 lb. bay scallops (cut in half if using sea scallops)

2 cups imitation crab meat, flaked, cut in half if very large pieces (or real lump crab meat if available)

2 cups half & half  

1 tsp. salt

1/2 tsp. ground black pepper

2 tsp. paprika

2 Tbsp. flour

 

Preparation:

 

 

Melt the butter in a 5-quart pot over medium heat. Add the onion, bell peppers and minced garlic; cook for 3 to 5 minutes until softened. 

 

 

 

  

  

 

 

Increase heat to high; add the diced potatoes, corn and water (or stock) to the pot. Bring to a boil, then reduce heat back to medium and simmer for 10 to 15 minutes, until the potatoes are fork-tender.

 

 

 

 

 

Add the shrimp and scallops to the pot. Cook gently for 3 to 5 minutes until the shrimp turn pink and the scallops are opaque. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

While the shrimp and scallops are cooking, whisk together the half & half, salt, pepper, paprika and flour.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Add imitation (or real) crab meat. Reduce heat to low, gently stir whisked mixture into pot.  Let mixture simmer for 3 to 5 minutes until hot, but do not let it boil after adding the dairy.

 

 

 

 

Seafood Chowder

 

Can the chowder be frozen even though it has dairy mixed in?  Yes, use freezer safe containers, leaving a 2-inch gap from the lid.  Label with date and can be stored for up to 3 months.

To reheat frozen chowder, thaw completely in the refrigerator.  Place the soup into a stove top pot, and let it heat up on low and slow, stirring occasionally, until hot.  Do Not bring to a boil on high heat, nor use a microwave, as this will break apart the dairy and cause it to curdle.

Mary Cokenour

 

 

Got to Have Faith.

“I got faith (Faith) in you, baby.

I got faith (Oh) in you now.

And you've been such a, such a good friend to me (Me).

Know that I love you somehow (Love you somehow).

I met you, hallelujah, I got faith (Faith).”

“Faith” by Stevie Wonder and Ariana Grande; sung at the end of “Sing” and the squid are dancing/swimming.

Oh yes, due to the Babylon Fire, we here in San Juan County have had our faith tested.  Faith in whatever beliefs we have, faith in firefighters, other responders and agencies fighting the fire, and faith in ourselves.  How did we react, not just personally, but towards others?  This has been a severe test in faith.

Ah, but enough about the fire that has been on our minds, and practically our front doors, for over three weeks.  Alright, yes, the fire forced many to reminisce about the structures that were lost, and all the good times hiking, camping or just pleasurable times in our forest.  So, to take our minds elsewhere, if just for a short time, follow me on my childhood reminiscence.

Sheepshead Bay is a waterfront neighborhood in southern Brooklyn, New York. Famous for its maritime history and piers, the area offers fresh seafood, waterfront promenades along Emmons Avenue, and party/fishing boats. It's a 5-minute ride to Coney Island, and 14-minutes to the New York Aquarium.

During the summer, we would occasionally make a day of visiting either Coney Island or the Aquarium.  Time was always made to get to Sheepshead Bay when the fishing boats were due back in.  The fishermen would lay out their catches of the day for customers to choose from, and purchase.  Hold onto your wallets folks, a three-pound sea bass went for one dollar!  There were also flounder, bluefish, cod, striped bass and squid.  Squid is what I’m going with today.

 

 

 

Now, now, now, before you start gagging, don’t be judging if you haven’t even tried it.  Squid is a low-calorie, nutrient-dense seafood packed with protein, vitamin B12, copper, zinc, and selenium, and heart-healthy Omega-3 fatty acids.  By the way, squid is typically called “calamari”, so you might have eaten it, not knowing its true origin.

While stuffed squid is delicious, I have to admit that deep fried calamari, dipped in a rich, chunky marinara sauce is the best overall.  Even now, if it’s on a menu, usually as an appetizer, we order it; unfortunately, tentacles are not included, and we really like those.  It is less costly for a restaurant to cut the body (mantle) into rings, while the arms (where the suckers are located) and tentacles are few.  However, no authentic Italian restaurant would serve calamari without tentacles.  Brought to North America, in the early 20th century, by Italian immigrants, this battered-and-fried dish exploded in popularity in the 1970s.  Remember Billy Joel’s song, "Movin' Out (Anthony's Song)", 1977?  He mentions Mama Leone, and yes, we have eaten in that restaurant; talk about the most amazing Italian dishes.  Sorry, it was forced to close in 1994 when rent hikes went out of control in NYC.

Squid dishes are not just found in Italian cuisine:

 

·         Italian (Calamari Fritti): Often lightly dusted in flour, fried until crispy, and served with a lemon wedge and a side of marinara sauce.  

 

Fried Calamari - Rings and Tentacles

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

·         Croatia: Fried Calamari: A casual staple. Often coated in light flour, deep-fried, and served with a squeeze of lemon and a side of French fries or tartar sauce.

       Stuffed Squid: Squid tubes are stuffed with a mixture of breadcrumbs, garlic, parsley,       

       and sometimes the chopped tentacles, then simmered in a rich tomato or wine sauce

       Lignje na žaru (Grilled Squid): The most celebrated preparation. Fresh squid are lightly

       brushed with high-quality olive oil, garlic, and parsley, then quickly grilled over an open

       flame. It is typically served with blitva (a classic side dish of sautéed Swiss chard and   

       boiled potatoes).

Crni Rižot (Black Risotto): A national coastal delicacy. Rice is simmered with squid or cuttlefish ink, giving it a striking black color and rich, briny flavor

·         Greek (Kalamarakia): A beloved tavern staple, typically soaked in milk before being breaded and fried, and served with tzatziki or fresh lemon juice.  

·         Asian Cuisines: In Chinese, Japanese, and Korean cultures, squid is often prepared as Ikayaki (grilled whole squid) or as salt-and-pepper fried squid, frequently sold as street food.  

·         Oceania & South Africa: It is a standard, deep-fried option at local fish-and-chip shops.

Whenever we travel to Salt Lake City, we always make time to shop at the Chinatown Supermarket: https://chinatown-supermarket.com/, and they offer an amazing selection of fresh and frozen seafood.  It is a major complex of stores, bakeries, restaurants and market representing Asian cuisines – Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Vietnamese, Thai, Filipino, and Taiwanese.  Visiting SLC, this is a highly recommended place to visit.

Recipe time!  The recipe for Scrumptious Stuffed Squid comes from Westchester Magazine: (https://westchestermagazine.com/food/stuffed-squid-recipe/), May 6, 2024, by Gregory Thomas.  It is from Dobbs Ferry Lobster Guys (Dobbs Ferry, NY), owned by the DiMeglio family who began a lobster fishing business in Brooklyn’s Mill Basin back in the 1960s.  I have made it, and it’s exactly like grandma used to make.  Oh, I did make a slight change by adding extra shrimp to cook in the sauce, and cheese tortellini as a side.

 

Scrumptious Stuffed Squid

Ingredients:

4 large, whole fresh squid (about 6 inches long)

2-3 Tablespoons olive oil for frying

2 (28-ounce) cans of tomato sauce (I used crushed for extra chunkiness)

1 cup Italian seasoned bread crumbs

5 large deveined shrimp, chopped (I used a 1-lb package, so the extra into the sauce)

4 medium eggs

10 pignoli/pine nuts, chopped

1 Tablespoon flat-leaf parsley, chopped

½ Tablespoon fresh garlic, chopped

Directions:

 

Cleaned squid is available in many stores, cleaning a whole squid is easy.  Do this by grasping the tail end of the squid, gently twisting off the head, and removing innards and interior cartilage. The skin may be left or removed. Leave the body of the squid whole.

 

 

 

 In a large bowl, combine bread crumbs, chopped shrimp, eggs, chopped pignoli/pine nuts, parsley, and garlic. Let the stuffing sit for about 5 minutes.

 

 

 

 

Fill each squid tube ¾ full with the stuffing and close ends with a toothpick. Be careful to leave space at the top of the tube to prevent the squid from splitting open when frying.

 

 

 

 

Over medium heat, add the olive oil to a frying pan large enough for all four squid. Once the oil is hot, carefully add the stuffed squid to the pan. Cook each side of the squid (about 3 minutes per side).

 

 

 

 

Reduce the heat. Add the tomato sauce and cover. Simmer the squid for about a ½ hour. Gently flip the stuffed squid two or three times while cooking.

 

Add Shrimp Last 5 Minutes of Cooking.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Salt to taste. Serve stuffed squid warm with the tomato sauce and accompaniment of your choice.

 

Servings 2-4 servings

Please don’t eat this dish while watching “Sing”, the squid will get highly insulted.

Mary Cokenour

 

 

 

 

 

 

Butchering Monticello.

Imagine, if you can, living during the 1880s.  Pioneers had traveled over desolate landscapes, losing many a wagon wheel, but not one life, not even one of the oxen pulling those wagons.

Settling in Bluff, alongside the San Juan River, the pioneers still endured hardships.  There was the lack of food supplies, as gardens and farms needed to be cultivated.  They were able to trade with local Native tribes, those that were willing to; the Carlisle cattle ranchers butchered and sold what they asked top dollar for.  Of course, the army sent soldiers to patrol the county, make sure government surveyors and expeditions kept safe, and keep peace between the pioneers, Natives and ranchers.  While the army provided provisions to their men, it was not unusual for an expectation of meals to be provided from the pioneers.  Meals in exchange for safety, not a bad deal, right?

Around the end of 1886 to beginning 1887, it was decided that expansion of settlements was needed, and a prime focus was finding more water sources along Montezuma Creek, and within the Blue Mountains.  One settlement that became firmly established was Monticello, and while much of the land was cleared previously by the Colorado ranchers, there was still much to be done.  To truly get the gist of what life was like, I, once again, recommend reading the first issue of Monticello Journal, A History of Monticello Until 1937, by Harold George and Fay Lunceford Muhlestein.  There is an issue at the local library, and copies for sale at the San Juan Record.  After reading it, and knowing yourself, it truly will make you wonder, “Would I have survived being one of the pioneers?”.

The focus though, of this article, is on the establishment of a business surely needed in Monticello…Butchering.  Besides housing for the residents, businesses needed to be established (sort of what we desperately need now as well), since traveling to larger towns, or cities, would take days into weeks.  While growing vegetables and other crops was taking a firm hold, nutrition called for sources of proteins.  Fish and birds, when caught, could provide for some, but, again, getting beef from the Colorado ranchers was the primary source, and that didn’t charge cheap.

Ah, but eventually lawyers were able to prove that the ranchers had no legal foot hold all over San Juan County.  They were forced to either establish property deals, or leave the area; and many had to sell off cattle to the local residents.  Sheep and pigs were later introduced to the area, but these herds did not fare well, and cattle dominated.

In, 1909, the Enlarged Homestead Act, provided 320 acres of non-irrigable land for the purpose of farming.  The areas set aside for this were east and north of Monticello, and welcome to the birth of homesteading and dry farming.  Dry farming?  Dry farming is a technique relying on soil moisture conservation to grow crops like winter wheat without irrigation. Local farmers combat arid conditions by limiting plowing and using drought-resistant seeds.  One such homesteader was Hans Jensen, arriving in 1911, by horse and wagon; he lived on his land, in a tent, and daily worked his land.  Only 5’5” tall, 125 lbs., he determinedly worked as having his own thriving farm was his sincere goal.  There must have been more to this man than meets the eye, as the mayor’s daughter, Adella Adams, eventually agreed to marry him.  Oh, she could have had anyone, considering she came from money, but living in Hans’ tent showed how much she loved him as well.

 

Hans Jensen, photo by Dawn Joyce Boyle.

In 1921, Hans built a small building which became his butcher shop.  With no refrigeration equipment invented yet, he, and Duke Edwards, who worked for Hans, would cut out 100-pound blocks of ice, bury then in dirt, and cover with sawdust during the winter.  In warmer weather, the blocks were hefted onto the roof of the building (Hans had built an insulated box), and this helped keep the provisions cool.  Customers could come to him for cuts of beef or pork, but it was not unusual to see Hans delivering to homes further outside the town, in his Ford Model-T pickup truck.

Hans, Della, and their children (as they grew older) had strong work ethics which helped them prosper, and the City Meat Market became a much needed and wanted business in Monticello.  Now I could go on and on about Hans and his family, and eventually how Blue Mountain Foods, and Meats, became the strongest businesses for the butchering, and the purchasing of meats, fish and poultry.  Instead, I will refer you to an article, in the San Juan Record, Hans and Della Jensen – short in stature, tall in life, 04/28/2010, written by Bill Boyle, grandson of Hans Jensen, and owner of the San Juan Record.   Or, if you happen to have, or can get a copy of, Blue Mountain Shadows, Volume 31/Winter 2005; pages 41-44 have the story of Hans, his family and the development of, not just the business of butchering, but the City Meat Market/Mercantile, including photos.

 

So, how does all this historical rambling of mine lead into a recipe?  Alright, stay with me here…the original members that followed Brigham Young and John Smith came from the east coast.  On the east coast was another group, the Amish, who had come to the United States for religious freedom.  Culturally, it was not unusual for their recipes to have come from their old countries, and carried across the US with those heading to, first Illinois, and ending up in Utah.  Another business that needed to be established were granaries and flour mills, as bread goods were a serious staple for existence, and that meant goods such as noodles and pasta as well.

The recipe I am giving you is called “Pioneer Beef and Noodles”, brought to Utah by the pioneers, and influenced by the Amish.  The recipe is simplistic with the use of wide noodles, created with the flour purchased from the mill, and beef from the local butcher.  Another cultural influence came from the Scandinavians and Slavics, as adding sour cream to the mix, and safe wild mushrooms, would bring us to a simmering pot of Stroganoff.   

 

 

 

In my recipe, I use an Italian herbal mixture and tagliatelle pasta, but that’s creative license on my part, so wide noodles would be more authentic.  With the seasonings, the pioneers used either what they brought with them, or what the Native tribes taught them to be safe and flavorful.

 

 

 

Pioneer Beef and Noodle Skillet Dish

Ingredients:

1 lb. ground beef (93/7)

1 large onion, chopped

3-4 cloves garlic, minced

4 cups beef broth

1 Tbsp. Worcestershire sauce

1 tsp. Italian herbal mix

8-12 oz. wide egg noodles, uncooked (or tagliatelle pasta for a more Italian twist)

1/2 cup sour cream (optional)

 

Preparation:

 

 

 

 

In a large skillet or Dutch oven, brown the ground beef with onion and garlic over medium-high heat. Drain excess fat.

 

 

 

 

Stir in beef broth, Worcestershire sauce, and seasonings. Bring to a boil.

 

 

 

Add uncooked egg noodles, cover, and reduce heat to low. Simmer for 12-15 minutes until noodles are tender, stirring occasionally.

 

 

 

Option: Stir in sour cream for creaminess.  For a more “stroganoff” type texture, add one cup of sour cream.  To get even closer to stroganoff, add a cup of chopped mushrooms when browning the beef, onions and garlic.

 

Serves 4-6.

Mary Cokenour 

 

Good Fortune and Feasting for Winter Solstice.

“The boar's head in hand bring I, 

Bedeck'd with bays and rosemary.

And I pray you, my masters, be merry.   

As many as are at the feast.”

~The Boar’s Head Carol”, 15^th century British Christmas carol~

Calendar wise, we are still, technically in the season of autumn.  Outside though, there is snow on the mountains; occasional hail, rain or sleet falls (hey, Mother Nature has multiple personality disorder, just go with the flow of it), and temperatures cold enough to freeze a runny nose.  In other words, the weather is screaming, “Winter!!!”.

For 2025, the Pagan holiday of Yule, or what the common majority call Winter Solstice, will be on December 21^st.  This is the shortest day of the year which means the fewest hours of daylight and the longest night when the northern hemisphere is tilted farthest from the sun.  As the days progress, more daylight will begin to show until the longest day of the year in June, or summer solstice.  Winter is a time for the earth to fall into deep slumber and regain energy throughout its time of sleep, and our ancient ancestors showed thankfulness with celebration.

Foods served during the feasting (dependent on regional location and timeline era) consisted of hearty, preserved, and spiced ingredients that symbolized warmth, and full larders for the harsh winter months.

Savory Main Dishes

Meats: Roasted pork (wild boar or pigs) ham, goose, beef, smoked fish, and sauce meatballs.

Sides: Root vegetables (potatoes, squash, carrots), stuffing, hearty breads, and pickled items.

Soups: Remnant soups made with leftover meats and vegetables.

Sweets & Baked Goods

Cakes & Breads: Yule log cake, gingerbread (Lebkuchen), fruitcake, spiced cookies (caraway, shortbread), saffron buns, and rich fruit breads.

Puddings & Pies: Figgy pudding, mince pies, and pumpkin pie.

Candies: Fudge, peanut brittle, peppermint bark, and chocolate truffles.

Drinks

Spiced Ales/Wines: Mulled wine, wassail (Lamb's Wool with ale, apples, spices), and spiced mead (honey wine).

Hot Drinks: Hot chocolate, hot buttered rum, and ginger tea.

Other: Eggnog, cider, and homemade fruit-infused spirits like Sloe Gin.

Fruits & Nuts

Citrus: Oranges and lemons.

Other Fruits: Apples, pears, cranberries, and dried fruits (figs, raisins).

Nuts: Hazelnuts, walnuts, pecans, often added into baked goods.

Which now brings me back to the Boar’s Head Carol that began this article.  Pork, namely wild boar and pigs, were an essential celebration meat, going back eons.  Pagan feasts sacrificed wild boars, and the roasted meat was then eaten to ensure good fortune and feasting during winter.  Ah, but what about God forbidding the consumption of pork by the Hebrews?  God forbade pork in the Old Testament (Leviticus, Deuteronomy) to set Israelites apart from pagan nations (all ancient cultures that worshipped Polytheism, or the worship of multiple gods).  This prohibition was a mark of holiness, cultural identity, and separation from the worship of false idols.

As Christianity emerged, many pagan beliefs, traditions and celebrations were incorporated to make an easier transition into this new religion.  So, the eating of pork became a popular tradition for Christmas, and even a traditional welcome for the New Year. The boar's head was the centerpiece at medieval Christmas feasts, symbolizing triumph over evil, presented with great ceremony with an apple in its mouth, and accompanied by the singing of the famous "Boar's Head Carol".  As wild boar began to become scarce, pigs specially bred to immense sizes, became the perfect substitute.

…and now for a pork recipe that would please the pagan souls of our ancient ancestors.  No!  Not how to roast and serve a pig’s head; had you scared there for a second, right?

 

Pork Chops in Barbecue Sauce

 

Ingredients:

 3 Tbsp. olive oil

2 tsp. salt

1 tsp. ground black pepper

8 boneless pork chops trimmed of all fat

2 large onions, julienned

4 tomatoes, seeded and chopped

1 bottle (18.5 oz.) Sweet Baby Ray’s Sweet & Spicy Barbecue Sauce

Preparation:

In a large 12-inch skillet, heat oil on medium-high heat.  Mix salt and pepper together and sprinkle over one side of pork chops.  Place chops in skillet, seasoned side down; sear for one-minute, flip chops and sear other side for one-minute.

 

Spread onions, then tomatoes over pork chops; pour barbecue sauce over all.  Let cook for 10 minutes, moving the ingredients around slightly to let the barbecue sauce seep downwards to the chops.  Reduce heat to low, cover and let cook for another 10 minutes.

 

 

 

 

 

Serve with sides of potato and vegetable; however, number of servings is dependent on size of chops.

For us, I added a side of mashed potatoes loaded with Vermont white cheddar, and I tend to use yellow (golden) potatoes as they are buttery in flavor, and come out ultra smooth in texture.  The vegetable was a flat or snap bean, called Romano or Italian green beans, which have a naturally sweet flavor, and firm texture to ordinary green beans.

Sleep well Earth, Sleep well Nature, and we look forward to your return in Spring.

Mary Cokenour 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ghosts of Theatres Past.

 

Young's Theater

 

Opera House - Monticello Memories Calendar - 1988

 

 The Opera House aka Young’s Theatre has a history rich in entertainment.  Originally built in 1907, it was a community center for Monticellians to play basketball, put on plays, hold dances or watch movies (silent ones of course).  In 1918, a severe snowstorm dumped so much upon the building’s roof, it completely collapsed.  Along came Alfred Young, who built a new building, in a different location, and called it Young’s Theatre. Naming things after one’s self is definitely a way to be remembered.

The Theatre remained opened until 1931, and then was purchased by…, San Juan Record, May 10, 1934, page 5, “Marie M. Ogden last week purchased the Young show hall, a well-known building which has been idle for two or three years. It is expected that a community house will be made, that is, it will be converted into a place for her people to stop for rest while considering their future activities in this county.” 

However, in 1935, the controversy over the death of Home of Truth member, Edith Peshak, forced Marie Ogden to close the theatre, and it has remained closed since that time.  While the Monticello Community Foundation made many attempts to obtain funding, to renovate and save the building, it, sadly didn’t happen.  Now it is scheduled to be demolished as the San Juan County Public Safety Building Expansion Project plans to remodel and expand the existing facility, which houses the Sheriff's Department, courts, and corrections.

However, entertainment was not lost to the citizens of Monticello.  Mr. and Mrs. Claude Foy opened their first movie theatre, on Main Street, June 15, 1936. Then, in 1939, they opened a larger 120-seat theatre, located in the Moab Garage warehouse, which Mr. Foy also managed.   The first movie featured was “Young Mr. Lincoln”, with Henry Fonda. The seating was eventually increased to 225, and in 1953, Mr. and Mrs. Harry Randall bought the theatre, but alas, it too closed down.

 

The Little Theater - Cinema Treasures (https://cinematreasures.org/theaters/67616)

 

 

Personal story time!  Bill Boyle, editor of the San Juan Record, related, to yours truly, a story about his mother.  During the 1930s, she would go to the theatre daily, and with leading actors such as Cary Grant, Clark Gable, Humphrey Bogart, Robert Montgomery and Errol Flynn…hubba hubba, someone get me some cold water please!

In 2015, the San Juan Record’s editor hosted a haunted hayride, The Monticello Ghost Tour, and related ghostly stories of various buildings around the city.  This was one of the best events for Pioneer Weekend, so Bill, please bring it back, I’m begging you!!!  Anyway, the San Juan Credit Union, in 2015, was the former location of the movie theatre; the rooms over the San Juan Pharmacy (now Main Street Drug) were used for storage for the theatre.  Monticello was making headlines all over the United States when an armed gunman was noticed in the upper window.  A young police officer, Kent Adair (Monticello's long time Chief of Police for 34 years) deftly disarmed the culprit with an expert karate chop.  Only to find out he had knocked off the arm of "Rambo", a large cardboard display of Sylvester Stallone; Kent's call in to other officers..."The suspect has been disarmed."  

 

If you’re interested in seeing what The Monticello Ghost Tour was all about, go to my travel blog posting at: https://www.southwestbrowneyes.com/2015/08/hayriding-to-meet-ghosts-of-monticello.html

Now, after all that researching to find details and photos of the old theatres, I am hungry!  How about a comforting plate of creamed chicken over country biscuits?  The best part about this recipe is that you can make this dish over and over, but with different flavor enhancements.  This is a semi-homemade recipe, so using “cream of …” soups for the sauce making.  Two cans (10.75 oz.) of cream of chicken gives that downhome chicken taste that is so satisfying.  Use one can of cream of chicken and one can of cream of celery or cream of potato, you’ve got pot pie.  For a more savory taste, one can of cream of chicken plus one can of cream of mushroom; and adding some sliced mushrooms into the mesh won’t hurt either.  By the way, I boiled the chicken breasts, in salted water, over medium-high heat, about 20 minutes, and then diced it up.

 

Creamed Chicken

 

Ingredients:

1 can (10.75 oz.) condensed cream of chicken soup

1 can (10.75 oz.) cream of (see variations above)

1 cup half n’ half

1 (12 oz.) bag frozen peas, thawed and drained

¼ tsp. ground black pepper

2 cooked chicken breasts, shredded or diced

Preparation:

In a saucepan or large skillet, over medium-high heat, combine contents of the soup(s) plus half n’ half, and whisk until smooth.

 

Two chicken breasts, boiled in salted water, then diced.

 

Add in peas, black pepper and chicken; stir and let cook until bubbles begin to form around interior wall of pan.

 

Serve immediately over biscuits, rice, or mashed potatoes.

Makes 6 servings.

So, put on a movie, and enjoy a bowl full of creamed chicken.  Um, don’t watch a very scary movie though, don’t want you throwing that bowl of food up in the air.

Mary Cokenour