496 North Main Street (Hwy 191)
Monticello, UT, 84535
Phone: (435) 587-2255
Website: http://www.dougssteakandbbq.com/
Hours of Operation:
Thursday thru Monday, 5pm – 10pm; Closed Tuesday and Wednesday
Knowing I was moving to the Southwest, my biggest thrill
was, “Yes, all the barbeque I could ever want!” but that was not to be. In fact, there was a severe lack of this type
of culinary delight within San Juan County.
Karen and Doug Whipple, owners of the Peace Tree Café and Juice Bar
restaurants decided it was time to rectify this atrocity upon diners.
Property for sale, across from the Monticello Peace Tree,
had just dropped in price; and they pounced on this like a mountain lion had
stalked an Abert’s squirrel. Purchase
the property they did, and the planning began.
While plumbing may have been in Doug’s, and son Eli’s, blood, so was
food…good food, lip smacking, finger licking, I want more of this, food! The Whipples are foodies, so is it any wonder
they get along so well with other foodies, like the Cokenours!?! Reading through books geared towards smoking
(they and I agree that Smoke and Spice by Cheryl and Bill Jamison is the
Bible of smoking foods), experimentation began.
Unwrapping the paper, setting the brisket onto a cutting board, the aroma assails the nostrils causing salivation immediately. The crust of a secretive spice mixture is glistening; the ends cut off to be saved for other uses. Eli begins slicing; a watchful eye keeps the hand steady for 1/8 – ¼ inch slices of heavenly goodness. Cutting against the grain, never with, taking a bite out of the first slice, the flavorful, tender meat begins to dissolve inside the mouth. Slight shivers as the angels sing the “Hallelujah” chorus; alright, so I’m exaggerating a tad, but it could happen. Anyway, I have tried brisket at many a barbeque joint, and Doug’s has the most outstanding!
Eli is also part of a dynamic duo; with Greg, they are the “Grill Masters”! These two have made the term, “flipping burgers” into an art form. Half pounders of a mixture of 1/3 beef short rib, 1/3 ground chuck and 1/3 ground brisket; even after cooking, they are easily a half-inch thick! Oh, the char, the char brings to mind grilling in the outdoors, the lick of flames as moisture drips down. Using a digital thermometer, internal cooking temperatures are checked to get the customer’s desired doneness. From rare to medium-well, your wish is their command. Don’t dare ask for well done, no hockey pucks served on a bun, just on the television screens depicting sports games of football, baseball, hockey and racing.
Pitchers of Moab Brewery beer will make it all slide down your gullet so smooth and easily; that is until the opposing team gets a touchdown. Hankering for a mixed cocktail, bartender and mixologist Nicole will put a punch in your punch, a dance in your step and bring a smile to your lips. This sassy sweetheart knows her liquors and how to mix them up just right. Fancy a margarita, that salt around the rim is Holyoak Smoked Salts (pure vanilla extract and bath soaps as well) located right here in Monticello. Now that’s local sourcing!
Doug’s Steak and BBQ does a good amount of their food sourcing from local businesses, but if they cannot find an ingredient they must have, then it’s Utah only, like Applewood Beehive.
You might be asking why, why do they all care so much? Simple really, the sustainability of a small town relies on its businesses. From locals to visitors, showing passion encourages people to come, and come often; it encourages visitors to Monticello to stay, play, eat and have a grand time.
Let’s put it all in a nutshell, Doug’s Steak and BBQ is
family friendly, casual dining, perfect for sports enthusiasts, large groups
are always welcome, and catering is available for parties and events. If you have not visited Doug’s yet, here’s
your invitation; what are you waiting for, get on over there and eat up!?!

Mary Cokenour